Price Guide - P
| Loose Price | MIB Price | Pony Name | Release Year | Release Type | Store or Country Exclusive |
Price Valid as of Date | Price Ref |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $8-10 | Paradise Island | 2007 | Best Friends | 6/09 | tp | ||
| $4-6 | Paradise Palms | 2005 | Dream Design | 3/09 | tp | ||
| Paradise Palms | 2005 | Limited Edition Numbered Ponies | WorldinAdvance | ||||
| $6-8 | Party Cake | 2007 | Best Friends | 6/10 | tp | ||
| Peach Blossom | 2006 | Crystal Design | |||||
| $3-4 | Peach Surprise | 2005 | w/ Tea Lily | Avon | 9/09 | arena | |
| Peach Surprise | 2006 | Set w/ Water Fountain | JC Penney | ||||
| Peach Surprise | 2006 | Sleepover Dreams | Discount Chain | ||||
| Peach Surprise | 2008 | Sleepover Dreams | |||||
| Peachie Keen | 2005 | Single | Discount Chain | ||||
| $3-6 | Peachy Pie | 2004 | Dance Studio bonus Sparkle pony | Walmart | 3/09 | tp | |
| Peachy Pie | 2004 | Limited Edition Numbered Ponies | WorldinAdvance | ||||
| $4-6 | Peachy Pie | 2004 | Sparkle | 3/09 | tp | ||
| $8-12 | Pearly Pie | 2007 | Pegasus | 6/09 | tp | ||
| $3-5 | $4-8 | Penny Candy | 2005 | Single | Target | 5/09 4/10 |
arena |
| $6-10 | Pepperberry | 2004 | Special Release | KB Toys | 6/09 | tp | |
| $3-5 | Periwinkle | 2004 | Celebration Salon Value Pack w/ Triple Treat, Periwinkle, Skywishes | 6/09 | tp | ||
| $3-5 | Periwinkle | 2004 | Jewel | 6/09 | tp | ||
| $3-5 | Periwinkle | 2004 | Sweet Reflections Dress Shop | Sams Club | 6/09 | tp | |
| $3-5 | Petal Blossom | 2004 | Super Long Hair | 5/09 | arena | ||
| $3-5 | Petal Blossom | 2005 | Picnic | ||||
| $3-5 | Petal Blossom | 2004 | Super Long Hair w/ bonus Flower Flash | ||||
| $6-9 | Petal Dove (So-soft pony) |
2004 | "Baby Alive" | 5/09 | tp | ||
| Petite Petunia | 2006 | Let's Go (Super Long Hair) | International | ||||
| Piccolo | 2004 | Build-a-pony | Disney | ||||
| Piccolo | 2004 | Limited Edition Numbered Ponies | WorldinAdvance | ||||
| $3-4 | Piccolo | 2004 | Perfectly | 6/09 | tp | ||
| Piccolo | 2005 | Tea Time Fun | Discount Chain | ||||
| Pick-a-Lilly | 2004 | 2-pack Dress Up w/ Sunny Salsa | KB Toys | ||||
| $4-5 | Pineapple Paradise | 2004 | Limited Edition Numbered Ponies | WorldinAdvance | 5/09 | arena | |
| $4-5 | Pineapple Paradise | 2005 | Sunny Scents | 5/09 | arena | ||
| Pink Petals | 2007 | Breezies Parade | International | ||||
| $4-6 | Pink Sunsparkle | 2003 | Celebration Castle | 5/09 | tp | ||
| Pink Sunsparkle | 2004 | 3-pack w/ Fluttershy, Toola Roola | Target | ||||
| $4-6 | Pink Sunsparkle | 2004 | Celebration Castle bonus Romperooni | 5/09 | tp | ||
| Pink Sunsparkle | 2008 | 3-pack w/ Fluttershy, Toola Roola | |||||
| $4-5 | Pinkie Pie | 2003 | Glitter w/ charm | 6/09 | tp | ||
| Pinkie Pie | 2003 | Glitter w/ charm and bonus Charming Bday Video | |||||
| Pinkie Pie | 2003 | Limited Edition Numbered Ponies | WorldinAdvance | ||||
| $180-220 | Pinkie Pie (Licensing Show) | 2003 | Limited Release in bag | Licensing Show | 6/09 | tp | |
| $180-200 | Pinkie Pie (Licensing Show) | 2003 | Limited Release in box | 6/09 | tp | ||
| Pinkie Pie | 2004 | Disney Princess "Cinderella" | Disney | ||||
| Pinkie Pie | 2005 | Pinkie Pie bonus Bellaluna | Discount Chain | ||||
| Pinkie Pie II | 2003 | Glitter | |||||
| Pinkie Pie II | 2004 | Perfect Hair Set | Australia? | ||||
| Pinkie Pie II | 2005 | Whimsical Winter | |||||
| Pinkie Pie II | 2007 | Collector Edition Tin | Australia | ||||
| Pinkie Pie III | 2004 | Pie Party Fun | |||||
| Pinkie Pie III | 2005 | Easter Egg | |||||
| Pinkie Pie IV | 2007 | 4-pack DVD set | Australia | ||||
| Pinkie Pie IV | 2007 | Sharing Tea w/ Minty | MLP Live | ||||
| $4-6 | Pinkie Pie V (3d symbol) |
2007 | Favorite Friends | 3/10 | arena | ||
| $30-35 | $35-40 | Pinkie Pie VI | 2007 | Limited Release | MLP Fair | 3/09 | tp |
| Pinkie Pie VI | 2007 | Pony Party Book/CD | |||||
| Pinkie Pie VII | 2007 | Single w/ party hat | |||||
| Pinkie Pie VII | 2008 | 2-pack Dress up with Sweetie Belle | Toys R Us | ||||
| Pinkie Pie VII | 2008 | Bucket w/ Toola-Roola, Scootaloo | Australia | ||||
| Pinkie Pie VII | 2008 | Core Friends | |||||
| $5-7 | $20-40 | Pinkie Pie VII | 2008 | Inspirational Words Collector Set | 11/09 | arena | |
| Pinkie Pie VII | 2008 | Limited Release | Toy Fair/Press Kit | ||||
| Pinkie Pie VII | 2008 | Party Dress Up | |||||
| $4-5 | $5-7 | Pinkie Pie VII | 2008 | Single w/ Eyeshadow | 5/09 | arena | |
| Pinkie Pie VII | 2008 | Single w/ kite | |||||
| Pinkie Pie VII | 2008 | Single w/ kite | |||||
| Pinkie Pie VII | 2008 | Single w/ name on leg | |||||
| Pinkie Pie VII | 2008 | Single w/ name on leg and bonus DVD | |||||
| Pinkie Pie VII | 2008 | Special Day DVD | |||||
| Pinkie Pie VII | 2008 | Valentine | |||||
| Pinkie Pie VII | 2009 | Easter Egg | |||||
| Pinkie Pie VII | 2009 | Single | Discount Chain | ||||
| Pinkie Pie VII | 2009 | Valentine | |||||
| Pinkie Pie VIII | 2008 | Winter | |||||
| $40-70 | $50-75 | Pony Project (Black) | 2005 | Limited Release | NYC Pony Project Art Show | 4/09 9/09 |
tp tp |
| $75-125 | Pony Project (TAF Symbols) | 2005 | Limited Release | NYC Pony Project Art Show - VIP Only | 9/09 | tp | |
| $17-25 | $20-40 | Pony Project (White) | 2005 | Limited Release | SDCC | 9/09 | tp |
| $12-15 | $20 | Port-o-bella | 2004 | w/ Lickety-Split | Kmart | 6/09 3/09 |
tp tp |
| Precious Gem | 2006 | Fancy Hair Pony | |||||
| Precious Gem | 2006 | Fancy Hair Pony w/ bonus Rose Garden | International | ||||
| $15-18 | Precious Gem | 2006 | Fancy Hair Pony Bonus Pack w/ Secret Wish | 5/09 | tp | ||
| $20-30 | Pretty Palace | 2006 | Crystal Rainbow Castle Bonus | Walmart | 5/09 | arena | |
| $5 | Pretty Parasol | 2006 | Carriage Pony | 9/09 | arena | ||
| Pretty Pop | 2007 | Best Friends | |||||
| $4-6 | Princess Peppermint | 2004 | 4-pack | Toys R Us | 6/09 | tp | |
| $5-7 with access |
Pumpkin Tart | 2006 | Halloween | Target | 6/09 | tp | |
| Purple Petunia | 2007 | Breezies Parade | International | ||||
| $3-6 | $18-24 | Puzzlemint | 2006 | Grand Puzzleventure Game | 9/09 6/09 |
tp tp |
NOTE : The Price Reference column refers to where the estimated value came from.
tp = My Little Pony Trading Post
arena = My Little Pony Arena
ebay = Ebay :)